Difference between revisions of "SLGOGP Draft 1/Discuss 1 Structure"

Revision as of 21:11, 11 March 2008

Welcome!

Comments on structure:

The inability to modify the parent document destroys most of the utility of wikis.
Since our contributions can now only be made in the discussions sections, they become merely advisary, and hence will be mostly ignored.
This is not really a community approach to evolving a document, as it divides the AWG into Lindens with power over the document and minions with none, and so it does not encourage contributions.
The worst aspect of this by far however is that the protocol specification becomes the exclusive domain of Linden Labs, and not of the AWG. Since the document is not defining Second Life but is creating a generic interoperable protocol for all parties, it is inappropriate that this specification be under the sole control of Linden Labs. Morgaine Dinova 22:11, 11 March 2008 (PDT)

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
 Welcome!
+Comments on structure:
+* The inability to modify the parent document destroys most of the utility of wikis.
+* Since our contributions can now only be made in the discussions sections, they become merely advisary, and hence will be mostly ignored.
+* This is not really a community approach to evolving a document, as it divides the AWG into Lindens with power over the document and minions with none, and so it does not encourage contributions.
+* The worst aspect of this by far however is that the protocol specification becomes the exclusive domain of Linden Labs, and not of the AWG.  Since the document is not defining Second Life but is creating a generic interoperable protocol for all parties, it is inappropriate that this specification be under the sole control of Linden Labs. [[User:Morgaine Dinova|Morgaine Dinova]] 22:11, 11 March 2008 (PDT)