Difference between revisions of "Snowstorm Daily Scrum Archive"

From Second Life Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
(345 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
=Project Snowstorm Daily Scrum Archive=
{{Project Snowstorm Nav}}
__TOC__
<br clear="all"/>


== Wednesday, August 18, 2010 ==
== Sprint 16, ends 05.31.11 ==
 
== Wednesday, May 18 ==
=== General Notes ===
----
* Q OOO until further notice


===Team Status===
===Team Status===
----
----
 
==== Oz Linden ====
====Aimee====
----
----
<b>PAST</b><br />
<b>PAST</b><br />
* Merged first batch of Snowglobe build fixes from aimee_linden/viewer-development-import to viewer-development
* Much merging
* Staged some more into aimee_linden/viewer-development-import
* Assorted repairs to mesh branch merge
* Reviewing Windlight builds


<b>FUTURE</b><br />
<b>FUTURE</b><br />
* Merge from aimee_linden/viewer-development-import to viewer-development
* Submit storm-1100
* Pull in some more Snowglobe fixes
* Start on storm-1265
* Rinse and repeat


<b>IMPEDIMENTS</b>
<b>IMPEDIMENTS</b><br />
* None
* none


====Tofu====
==== Wolf Linden ====
----
<i>OOO</i>
 
 
====Oz====
----
----
<b>PAST</b><br />
<b>PAST</b><br />
* Snowglobe meeting
* Set up mailing lists for commit and build notices
** (build notices not yet flowing - commits work)
<b>FUTURE</b><br />
<b>FUTURE</b><br />
* Improve wiki page on hg workflow
* Working on getting an answer for Storm-565
* Get build notices from canonical build of viewer-development to list
* Office Hours


<b>IMPEDIMENTS</b><br />
<b>IMPEDIMENTS</b><br />
* (minor) Can't get ssh authentication to hg.secondlife.com/bitbucket.org working
* none


 
==== Grumpity ProductEngine ====
==== Merov ====
----
----
<b>PAST</b><br />
<b>PAST</b><br />
* Attended Snowstorm sprint planning meeting
* crashhunters
* Snowstorm sync: cloned and built http://bitbucket.org/lindenlab/viewer-development (Mac). Works like a charm except I can't get llkdu to load (loads openjpeg instead). This is germane to the next task.
* sprint cleanup
* LLKDU in viewer-development: I realized that Snowstorm doesn't load libllkdu.dylib on Mac even if present in the bundle. The same is true for SG2.0 at least for the version built on my machine. I need to investigate all that in the context of solving this "building with llkdu" issue for Snowstorm but it might be more general than just a Windows issue.
* some triage
* Snowglobe backlog: started a list and got it ready for the sprint meeting. Didn't get used eventually.
* Fielded lots of Snowglobe questions on #opensl and during a looong OH session
* Took care of my email backlog! Yes!
 
<b>FUTURE</b><br />
<b>FUTURE</b><br />
* LLKDU in viewer-development:
* crashhunters cleanup
* Snowstorm sync: do the Windows part
* VWR triage
 
* STORM-951
* PO build
* reports
<b>IMPEDIMENTS</b><br />
<b>IMPEDIMENTS</b><br />
* Snowglobe building questions/requests on #opensl consumed
* none
 
==== Q ====
----
<i>OOO</i>
 


==== Esbee ====
==== Vadim ProductEngine ====
----
----
<b>PAST</b><br />
<b>PAST</b><br />
* Posted public Snowstorm Backlog and Sprint Backlog
* Reported a crash in viewer-development.
* Ran our first inworld Sprint Planning Meeting
* Manual merge from viewer-development to the WLRS integration branch.
* Created Jiras for each user story we've taken on for Sprint 2
* WLRS repo Windows build issues: fixed one and handed another over to Paul.
* Responded to some SLCC and Snowstorm blog feedback
* Task STORM-1256 (Region environment settings editor):
 
** WIP. Investigating time synchronization between viewer and region.
<b>FUTURE</b><br />
* Jira bug triage for Sprint 2
* Assist team with Scrum tasks
* Continue to follow up on SLCC and Snowstorm blog feedback
* Overall Jira clean up
* Sync up with Oz
 
<b>IMPEDIMENTS</b>
* None
   
   
==== Paul ====
----
<b>PAST</b><br />
* BUG EXT-8588 (URL-like name of group is shown as hyperlink in group mini-inspector)
** Almost finished, but ran into a problem.  Reassigned to Anya with questions.
* BUG EXT-8672 ([HARD CODED] ALL LANGS  The word "Saved" is hard coded, in the long timestamp displayed in IM  when user is offline)
** In progress
<b>FUTURE</b><br />
<b>FUTURE</b><br />
*BUG  EXT-8672 ([HARD CODED] ALL LANGS The word "Saved" is hard coded, in the  long timestamp displayed in IM when user is offline)
* Continue with STORM-1256.
 
<b>IMPEDIMENTS</b>
* EXT-8588


<b>IMPEDIMENTS</b><br />
* none


==== Andrew ====
==== Andrey ProductEngine ====
----
----
<b>PAST</b><br />
<b>PAST</b><br />
*Task EXT-8425 ([HARD CODED] ALL LANGS: Unlocalized keyboard keys under Advanced menu > Shortcuts (French viewer)) reopened
* picked up 2.6.9 beta build r230161
**Pushed.
* verified yestarday's blockers - crash and help unavailability
*Bug EXT-8635 (Replace "no matches found" with "loading" in the My Outfits tab).
* passed smoke & integrity tests, refer to the IQA-164 for more details
**Yesterdays attempt with background fetching didn't work. Consluted with Serget again, fixed, sent for review.
* tested changes in scope of IQA-166, there is a bunch TPE cannot test. IQA-166 re-assigned back to Martin
* Bug EXT-6527 (IM chat history log in plain text mode looks ugly when displays avatar SLURLs).
**WIP.


<b>FUTURE</b><br />
<b>FUTURE</b><br />
*EXT-6527 (IM chat history log in plain text mode looks ugly when displays avatar SLURLs).
* pickup latest v-d build?


<b>IMPEDIMENTS</b><br />
<b>IMPEDIMENTS</b><br />
*Failed at resurrecting debug, despite much perversity.  Will clone repository again tomorrow. 
* none


 
==== Wolfpup Lowenhar ====
==== Vadim ====
----
----
<b>PAST</b><br />
<b>PAST</b><br />
*Organizational issues, including Snowstorm Sprint Planning meeting.
* Working inworld(this is part of testing localy built viewers).
*Task EXT-8564 (Add option fo take off wearables via "Wearing" Tab):
** Checking on horses and bundles, plus work on note cards for them.
**Committed.
* Deciding on what type of build to work on next.
* Bug EXT-8357 (ESC will not de-focus the sidebar):

* Run a Test build of Brad's must build faster Repository as a test on local system.
**Committed.
** Test Build took 8 minutes longer than normal and there was loss of functionality in most of the side panles.
* Bug EXT-4977 (After teleporting, opening/closing the side panel causes the screen to turn black):
* Local build after mesh code merge crashes on start.
**Resolved as not reproducible.
** This could be a merge issue that is causing the viewer to error in LLViewerTextureList::addImageToList: ASSERT (mInitialized).
** also looks to be same issue i had on linux testing the gpu viewer from storm-1100 .


<b>FUTURE</b><br />
<b>FUTURE</b><br />
*Bug EXT-8630 (Ctrl-Shift-W hides all chat until a viewer restart).
* Working inworld(this is part of testing localy built viewers).
* Find new tickets for our tasks in Snowstorm Sprint #2,  and assign them.
* Wait for crash on error to be fixed.
* Start on new sprint tasks.  


<b>IMPEDIMENTS</b><br />
<b>IMPEDIMENTS</b><br />
*none
* Getting Autobuild system and security software to play nicely on my system.


= Past Updates =
<b>May</b><br />
[[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/05172011 | 17]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/05162011 | 16]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/05132011 | 13]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/05122011 | 12]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/05112011 | 11]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/05052011 | 05]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/05042011 | 04]]


==== Sergey ====
<b>April</b><br />
----
[[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/04272011 | 27]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/04262011 | 26]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/04252011 | 25]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/04142011 | 14]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/04132011 | 13]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/04122011 | 12]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/04072011 | 07]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/04062011 | 06]]
<b>PAST</b><br />
*Critical bug (EXT-7083) Initial preferences are "G" but allow me to enter Moderate regions.
**Pushed fix.
Investigate if maturity rating can be removed from config. Perhaps not worth a separate task.
*Bug (EXT-7325) My Landmarks: "Show on Map" context menu item is enabled while "Map" button is disabled for selected landmark.
**Fixed. Uploaded for review.


<b>FUTURE</b><br />
<b>March</b><br />
*Bug (EXT-8697) My Landmarks: 'Cut' item should be greyed out in folder's context menu
[[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/03312011 | 31]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/03302011 | 30]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/03292011 | 29]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/03192011 | 19]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/03182011 | 18]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/03172011 | 17]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/03162011 | 16]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/03152011 | 15]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/03142011 | 14]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/03112011 | 11]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/03102011 | 10]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/03092011 | 09]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/03082011 | 08]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/03072011 | 07]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/03042011 | 04]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/03032011 | 03]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/03022011 | 02]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/03012011 | 01]]
** Bug (EXT-8699) 'Item Profile' panel isn't udated if change name of that item from 'Object contents' floater


<b>IMPEDIMENTS</b><br />
<b>February</b><br />
*none
[[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/02282011 | 28]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/02252011 | 25]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/02242011 | 24]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/02232011 | 23]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/02222011 | 22]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/02182011 | 18]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/02162011 | 16]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/02152011 | 15]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/02142011 | 14]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/02112011 | 11]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/02102011 | 10]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/02092011 | 09]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/02082011 | 08]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/02072011 | 07]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/02042011 | 04]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/02032011 | 03]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/02022011 | 02]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/02012011 | 01]] |


<b>January</b><br />
[[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/01312011 | 31]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/01282011 | 28]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/01272011 | 27]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/01262011 | 26]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/01252011 | 25]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/01242011 | 24]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/01212011 | 21]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/01202011 | 20]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/01192011 | 19]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/01182011 | 18]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/01142011 | 14]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/01132011 | 13]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/01122011 | 12]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/01112011 | 11]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/01102011 | 10]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/01062011 | 06]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/01062011 | 06]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/01052011 | 05]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/01042011 | 04]]


==== Anya ====
<b>2010</b><br />
----
<b>December</b><br />  
<b>PAST</b><br />
[[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/12302010 | 30]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/12232010 | 23]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/12222010 | 22]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/12212010 | 21]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/12202010 | 20]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/12172010 | 17]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/12162010 | 16]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/12152010 | 15]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/12142010 | 14]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/12132010 | 13]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/12102010 | 10]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/12092010 | 09]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/12082010 | 08]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/12072010 | 07]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/12062010 | 06]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/12032010 | 03]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/12022010 | 02]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/12012010 | 01]]
*mostly QA coordination issues
*appearance ownership


<b>FUTURE</b><br />
<b>November</b><br />  
*crashhunters
[[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/11302010 | 30]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/11292010 | 29]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/11242010 | 24]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/11232010 | 23]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/11222010 | 22]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/11192010 | 19]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/11182010 | 18]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/11172010 | 17]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/11162010 | 16]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/11152010 | 15]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/11122010 | 12]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/11112010 | 11]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/11102010 | 10]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/11092010 | 09]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/11082010 | 08]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/11052010 | 05]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/11042010 | 04]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/11032010 | 03]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/11022010 | 02]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/11012010 | 01]]
*discus future of PE's current backlog, other bugfixing within the big picture.


<b>IMPEDIMENTS</b><br />
<b>October</b><br />  
*none
[[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/10292010 | 29]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/10282010 | 28]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/10272010 | 27]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/10262010 | 26]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/10252010 | 25]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/10222010 | 22]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/10212010 | 21]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/10202010 | 20]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/10182010 | 18]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/10152010 | 15]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/10142010 | 14]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/10132010 | 13]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/10122010 | 12]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/10112010 | 11]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/10082010 | 08]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/10072010 | 07]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/10062010 | 06]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/10052010 | 05]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/10042010 | 04]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/10012010 | 01]]


<b>September</b><br />
[[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/09272010 | 27]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/09242010 | 24]] |
[[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/09212010 | 21]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/09202010 | 20]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/09172010 | 17]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/09162010 | 16]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/09152010 | 15]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/09142010 | 14]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/09132010 | 13]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/09092010 | 09]] | 
[[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/09082010 | 08]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/09072010 | 07]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/09032010 | 03]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/09022010 | 02]] |
[[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/09012010 | 01]]


== Past Updates ==
<b>August</b><br />
* [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/08162010 | Monday, August 16, 2010]]
[[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/08302010 | 30]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/08262010 | 26]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/08252010 | 25]] |
* Tuesday, August 17, 2010 - <i>No Daily Scrum today, Sprint 2 Planning took place</i>
[[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/08242010 | 24]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/08232010 | 23]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/08202010 | 20]] |
* ...
[[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/08192010 | 19]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/08182010 | 18]] | [[Snowstorm_Daily_Scrum_Archive/08162010 | 16]]

Latest revision as of 01:23, 19 May 2011


Sprint 16, ends 05.31.11

Wednesday, May 18

Team Status


Oz Linden


PAST

  • Much merging
  • Assorted repairs to mesh branch merge
  • Reviewing Windlight builds

FUTURE

  • Submit storm-1100
  • Start on storm-1265

IMPEDIMENTS

  • none

Wolf Linden


PAST
FUTURE

  • Working on getting an answer for Storm-565

IMPEDIMENTS

  • none

Grumpity ProductEngine


PAST

  • crashhunters
  • sprint cleanup
  • some triage

FUTURE

  • crashhunters cleanup
  • VWR triage
  • STORM-951
  • PO build
  • reports

IMPEDIMENTS

  • none

Vadim ProductEngine


PAST

  • Reported a crash in viewer-development.
  • Manual merge from viewer-development to the WLRS integration branch.
  • WLRS repo Windows build issues: fixed one and handed another over to Paul.
  • Task STORM-1256 (Region environment settings editor):
    • WIP. Investigating time synchronization between viewer and region.

FUTURE

  • Continue with STORM-1256.

IMPEDIMENTS

  • none

Andrey ProductEngine


PAST

  • picked up 2.6.9 beta build r230161
  • verified yestarday's blockers - crash and help unavailability
  • passed smoke & integrity tests, refer to the IQA-164 for more details
  • tested changes in scope of IQA-166, there is a bunch TPE cannot test. IQA-166 re-assigned back to Martin

FUTURE

  • pickup latest v-d build?

IMPEDIMENTS

  • none

Wolfpup Lowenhar


PAST

  • Working inworld(this is part of testing localy built viewers).
    • Checking on horses and bundles, plus work on note cards for them.
  • Deciding on what type of build to work on next.
  • Run a Test build of Brad's must build faster Repository as a test on local system.
    • Test Build took 8 minutes longer than normal and there was loss of functionality in most of the side panles.
  • Local build after mesh code merge crashes on start.
    • This could be a merge issue that is causing the viewer to error in LLViewerTextureList::addImageToList: ASSERT (mInitialized).
    • also looks to be same issue i had on linux testing the gpu viewer from storm-1100 .

FUTURE

  • Working inworld(this is part of testing localy built viewers).
  • Wait for crash on error to be fixed.

IMPEDIMENTS

  • Getting Autobuild system and security software to play nicely on my system.

Past Updates

May
17 | 16 | 13 | 12 | 11 | 05 | 04

April
27 | 26 | 25 | 14 | 13 | 12 | 07 | 06

March
31 | 30 | 29 | 19 | 18 | 17 | 16 | 15 | 14 | 11 | 10 | 09 | 08 | 07 | 04 | 03 | 02 | 01

February
28 | 25 | 24 | 23 | 22 | 18 | 16 | 15 | 14 | 11 | 10 | 09 | 08 | 07 | 04 | 03 | 02 | 01 |

January
31 | 28 | 27 | 26 | 25 | 24 | 21 | 20 | 19 | 18 | 14 | 13 | 12 | 11 | 10 | 06 | 06 | 05 | 04

2010
December
30 | 23 | 22 | 21 | 20 | 17 | 16 | 15 | 14 | 13 | 10 | 09 | 08 | 07 | 06 | 03 | 02 | 01

November
30 | 29 | 24 | 23 | 22 | 19 | 18 | 17 | 16 | 15 | 12 | 11 | 10 | 09 | 08 | 05 | 04 | 03 | 02 | 01

October
29 | 28 | 27 | 26 | 25 | 22 | 21 | 20 | 18 | 15 | 14 | 13 | 12 | 11 | 08 | 07 | 06 | 05 | 04 | 01

September
27 | 24 | 21 | 20 | 17 | 16 | 15 | 14 | 13 | 09 | 08 | 07 | 03 | 02 | 01

August
30 | 26 | 25 | 24 | 23 | 20 | 19 | 18 | 16